Female Education and School Competition: 1820-1850
Abstract
An examination of this forgotten episode in American school history reveals hitherto unremarked connections between what actually went on in classrooms and the ideas of social and educational reformers. The timing, the arguments, and the cast of characters of the attack on emulation suggest a close relationship between this phenomenon and the growing presence of females in schools. Its study allows us to see how a fact (girls in schools) prompted reconsideration of a school practice (competition for prizes) which had been taken for granted, and how rejection of the practice in turn was integrated into educational theory. At the same time, it illuminates the relationships between two larger themes in the intellectual history of antebellum America. The first of these is the image of woman as a source of stability in a period of aggressive expansion and growing economic competition. The second is the belief that the character of individuals shapes the character of society, a view which necessarily placed education at the center of reform and committed educators to shaping educational processes in accordance with grand goals. Educational reformers of the second quarter of the nineteenth century supported the extension and improvement of education for females. Their reasons for this support went beyond a belief in the enlightenment