historyofeducation.eu · Journals

The Quest for a Science of Education in the Nineteenth Century

James R. Robarts
History of Education Quarterly · 1968 · 8(4) · pp. 431

Abstract

NEEDED: A SCIENCE OF EDUCATION WHEN ONE READS the records of nineteenth-century educators as they wrestled the question, Is there a discipline of education? one finds them very often assuming or flatly asserting that there is or can be such a science and then devoting a major part of their attention to the need for the development of it. Throughout the period this need reflected two concerns: the quality of education and professional status. As early as 1825, James G. Carter, a leader in the normal school movement, claimed that false principles of instruction, unchanged since the restoration of learning several centuries earlier, were responsible for confusion in the minds of students, a waste of their time, a perversion of their talents, unnecessary taxes and wasted efforts of teachers. (i) Five years later, Carter told the American Institute of Instruction that the science of education was the basis of all human progress, though he conceded that he was talking about what it should be rather than what it was. However, he was convinced that, although the development of the science would be a slow process involving many minds, the task would go forward with a motion as steady and irresistable as that of the spheres. (2) President Francis Wayland, another powerful voice for educational reform in his age, who spoke at the same convention, agreed Carter that the science of education was the basis of progress in all

Science educationSociologySocial sciencePedagogy
Open in the catalogue DOI