John Dewey and the Polish Question: A Response to the Revisionist Historians
Abstract
TWO HISTORIANS, Clarence J. Karier and Walter Feinberg, recently have suggested that John Dewey's commitment to democracy was less than whole-hearted. This view rests in part on their use of a report submitted by Dewey to the Federal Government in 1918: Conditions Among the Poles in the United States: Confidential Report. (1) As Karier puts it, the report reveals Dewey as a conservative who was to flexible, experimentally managed, orderly social change, which included a high degree of manipulation. (2) A closer look at the report and its historical context, however, suggests precisely the opposite: Dewey is shown as strongly and personally committed to the democratic process and opposed to manipulative government. In addition, it is a revealing example of Dewey's efforts to connect his educational theories to more general social and political questions. The attention of John Dewey was directed to the Polish Question during a seminar he taught at Columbia in the winter of 1918. This seminar included Mrs. Levitas, an emigrant from Poland then working in a New York garment factory; Albert C. Barnes, who had made a fortune by developing and manufacturing an antiseptic; as well as Columbia graduate students, Irwin Edman and Paul and Brand Blanshard. Out of this seminar grew a project to study the Polish emigrant community in Philadelphia during that summer. Barnes, who proposed and financed the project, conceived of it as a practical test of Dewey's theories of social inquiry which would result in a ... plan, based upon first hand knowledge, to eliminate forces alien to a democratic internationalism and to promote American ideals in accordance with the principles announced by President Wilson in his various public