Old School Ties: The Public Schools in British Literature
Abstract
It has been said, jokingly, that the English public school is public because it is private, it is English because it teaches Latin, and it is a school because it emphasizes cricket. The paradoxes and contradictions of this important and typically British institution, however, have been the subject of more serious commentary, study, and research. Professor Reed's Old School Ties purports it to be such an enterprise. By concentrating on the views of leading intellectuals, largely novelists and poets, the author shows how, among this select group, a public school education was perceived to be contradictory to some of its highsounding purposes and ideals. Instead of fostering the spirit of independence and all the intellectual and moral virtues associated with a liberal education, the public schools stultified imagination and individualism, cowed the spirit, emasculated the minds of those who went through them, and nurtured all sorts of vice and moral turpitude. To the literary artist the whole public school experiment in building intellect, character, leadership, and an Empire was a fraud. Unlike those who saw in the schools the most perfect blending of intellectual, moral, and physical training that created the victors of Waterloo and the builders of a great Empire, the literary artists saw them as agencies of social and political control by the upper classes, and as dehumanizing machines which turned out perpetual adolescents, social snobs, and generally men devoid of basic human qualities such as love, feeling, empathy, and understanding. More than that: the public school was perceived to be a contributing factor in the disintegration of the Empire, the culture splits in the modern society, the alienation of the thirties, and all the social evils of twentieth-century Britain. These are serious indictments. An indictment of the public school is not merely a criticism of a theory of education; since the public school reflected certain social and cultural values and arrangements that pervaded British life and thought, and in large part helped perpetuate them, it is also an indictment against a theory of society and a theory of culture. The merit of Old School Ties is its comprehensive treatment of the views, mostly indictments, of an important segment of major British intellectuals ranging from Dickens and Samuel Butler, to Shaw, Alec Waugh, Maugham, Forster, Orwell, Aldous Huxley, W. H. Auden, and Henry Green. Inasmuch as the literary writer is, among other things, an acute social critic, students of o means the least of its valuable features is its bibliography; it is very prehensive and much of it is carefully and fully nnotated.