The False Dawn of the State University
Abstract
In the state Henry Pritchett once claimed, we find, conception of education from the standpoint of a whole people. . If, he continued, our American democracy were today called to give proof of its constructive ability, the State University and the public school which it crowns would be the strongest evidence of its fitness which it could offer.'l From commencement and inaugural addresses has come an endless stream of such praise for this great, and allegedly unique, institution; and one comes to wonder in the face of such talk why private universities and independent colleges continue to exist. But there have always been firm dissenting voices. When, for example, Columbia University's John W. Burgess considered the problem of locating a really great American university, he argued: