Standing on the Shoulders of Bowles and Gintis: Class Formation and Capitalist Schools
Abstract
In The German Ideology, Marx articulates one of his most famous claims. Paraphrased, it reads in essence that ruling class will give its ideas the form of universality and represent them as the only rational universally valid While there have been interpreters of this point who have chosen to see this process as a conscious conspiracy, for Marx it was considerably more complicated. For him, out of the constitutive conflicts and contradictions of capitalism there were certain specific tendencies that were generated. Among these tendencies was the natural production of principles, ideas, and categories that support the unequal class relations of that social formation.1 These ideas were under constant threat, however. They needed constant attention because hegemonic control was not guaranteed. Because of the class conflicts also generated out of, and causing, changes in that mode of production, there always exists the possibility of different ideological tendencies which could subvert the dominant ones. These are powerful points. They have led to an extensive amount of educational/political activity and historical scholarship. Some of the latter has been profoundly interesting, while some of it has been more than a little reductive and less adequate than it could be in understanding the utter complexity of, say, class relations under capitalism. One of the books that has stimulated, and been stimulated by, a good deal of this scholarship is Samuel Bowles and Herbert Gintis's historically important