The Jesuits and French Education: A Comparative Study of Two Schools 1852-1913
Abstract
THE PAST DECADE has witnessed a marked revival of interest in the role of the Catholic Church in nineteenth-century French education. Several scholarly works have examined this subject from a variety of directions. (1) This essay presents a detailed comparison of careerpreferences of graduates of the two most prestigious Jesuit schools of the period. Studying the progress of alumni of the College de 1'Immaculee-Conception (popularly referred to Vaugirard), and of the Ecole Sainte-Genevieve de la rue des Postes, permits an examination of similarities and differences between the two schools. It also provides a statistical basis for conclusions regarding the impact of these institutions on French society. These two establishments were the most widely known Jesuit schools in France; such, they received lavish praise from defenders of Jesuit education and harsh denunciation from those who feared its effects on the country. Both the enemies and the allies of the entire system of Catholic education regarded it, quite logically, as an inevitable rival to the state system. (2) The fact that most clerics were men of promonarchist sympathies led all anticlericals and many moderates to view Catholic education at least an implicit threat to the Third Republic. This attitude was buttressed by the indisputable success of the Jesuits in preparing their pupils for the entrance examinations for the grandes ecoles. Fears of a Jesuit complot to undermine republican institutions by means of inflitration of those institutions with graduates of Jesuit schools were widely bruited in the 1870s. (3) Were these fears justified? Certainly increasing numbers of students were attending Church-related secondary schools. Between 1854 and