historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Functions and Fantasies: Understanding Schools in Capitalist America

David K. Cohen, Bella H. Rosenberg
History of Education Quarterly · 1977 · 17(2) · pp. 113

Abstract

SCHOOLING IN CAPITALIST AMERICA (1) will make waves in the history of education, but it is only incidentally concerned with history. Rather, it is an effort to locate schooling in the social and economic context of capitalist society. The authors seek to offer a comprehensive account of the role schools have served in the American economic structure;they advance a critique of efforts to change or reform schools; and they suggest an alternative vision of how school reform should work. On the first point, Bowles and Gintis argue that U.S. schools' chief role has been to reproduce inequality in the larger society-to pass along differences arising in the social relations of production. In this the schools legitimate, reflect, and transmit inequality; they socialize students to inequality and the beliefs required to support it. But they neither cause inequality nor do they relieve it. On the second point, the authors argue that most school reform efforts have failed. In some cases the book says that reforms materialized but were wrong because they sought to reinforce the capitalist order; in others the reforms failed to materialize because they sought the opposite -more liberation or equality. Furthermore, those few efforts that succeeded in liberalizing or equalizing some aspects of schooling were failures: mere cosmetics to keep the contradictory face of capitalism from appearing too ugly. School reform, in their view, either fails because it succeeds in doing the economy's bidding or fails because it

CapitalismNeoclassical economicsPolitical scienceSociologyEconomicsEconomic systemLawPolitics
Open in the catalogue DOI