After the Emergence: Voluntary Support and the Building of American Research Universities
Abstract
IN 1908 AND 1909 science journalist Edwin E. Slosson visited and described fourteen of what he called Great American Universities. The volume of that title which he published still deserves place among most interesting books of this century on higher education. The members of his select group-California, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, and Wisconsin among state universities; Columbia, Harvard, Pennsylvania, Princeton, and Yale from descendents of colonial colleges; and Cornell, Johns Hopkins, Stanford, and Chicago from new endowed universities-these schools for most part led other institutions of higher education in numbers of students, size of their budgets, and scholarly achievements of their faculties. ' More than half-century later roughly same group of institutions became focus for another significant study, this time from an historical perspective: Laurence Veysey's Emergence of American University.2 The endpoint of Veysey's analysis occurs at same juncture as Slosson's observations. And both authors agree about one fundamental characteristic of these institutions by that date: they largely seemed to have evolved into single type that Slosson called the standard American university ... [a] peculiar combination which has evolved in United States of instruction and research, graduate and undergraduate students, letters and technology (382-83). Slosson was by far more sanguine about this development. Veysey felt that competitive emulation between universities had produced a dull standardization for whole (331); compartmentalization, which made coexistence of these varied tasks possible, he described as type of