Ethnicity, Religion and Class: Progressive School Reform in San Francisco
Abstract
MUCH OF THE LITERATURE appearing within the past decade on the reform and centralization of urban school governance throughout America from 1890 to 1920 has dwelled upon the influence of bureaucracy and social class to the neglect of very significant ethnic and religious factors. Only token recognition, if any, is granted to ethnicity and religion by Michael Katz and others who depict the centralization movement nearly exclusively as a class effort displaying an anti-working class bias and born out of an elitist thrust for power. From this perspective, the contests for school reform as outlined for New York, Boston and elsewhere appear one-dimensional in nature and over simplified. (1) In San Francisco, as we shall see, not only did elite centralizers cultivate working class support, but the contest for school reform found the working class divided among itself along religious and ethnic lines. The issue of centralization in San Francisco was not a simplistic contest between the so-called ruling class and the working class but a complicated situation in which ethnicity and religion played major roles. Several issues and leaders emerged for different reasons from different groups at different times and in different places during the years of the centralization movement. In San Francisco there were two phases of attempted centralization: the first following the conventional pattern described elsewhere, and the second described in detail in this study taking a different course. The central point of this analysis evolves from an examination of the second stage in which anti-Catholicism played a prominent part in achieving success for reformers. Because the public schools in San Francisco became a virtual battleground between Catholics and anti-Catholics, many of the native-born Protestant working class sided with elitist reformers on the issue of centralization and supplied much of the leadership for that effort. The working class clearly was not solidly opposed to the idea of centralization. The Irish and Italian working class was not only alienated from elite