The Ante-Bellum College Movement: A Reappraisal of Tewksbury's Founding of American Colleges and Universities
Abstract
FEW MONOGRAPHS in history of American higher education have been as influential or as frequently cited as Donald G. Tewksbury's Founding of American Colleges and Universities Before Civil War, With Particular Reference to Religious Influences Bearing Upon Movement. Frederick Rudolph, in a bibliographic essay on history of higher education, calls it the most durable and the most useful volume among several hundred titles in Teachers series, Contributions to Education. (1) Focusing on period from end of Revolution to beginning of Civil War, Tewksbury emphasizes extensive proliferation and exceedingly high rate of mortality of colleges, as well as religious influences upon them, sectarian competition, and concept of college. These themes have received prominent attention in discussions of ante-bellum in most subsequent histories of higher education. When Tewksbury's dissertation was published in 1932, virtually only general history of American higher education was Charles Franklin Thwing's narrative survey that had been published in 1906. Within past two decades, several histories have been published, beginning with Richard Hofstadter and Walter P. Metzger's influential study of academic freedom in American and universities. Hosftadter places blame for what he calls The Great Retrogression in The Old Time College primarily on multiplying and scattering of colleges as result of denominational sponsorship and sectarian competition. Frederick Rudolph, in his chapter entitled The Movement, also attributes college mania primarily to denominationalism, but he is not as negative as Hofstadter in assessing results. Although Theodore Crane,