historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Agustina Paglayan, Raised to Obey: The Rise and Spread of Mass Education Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2024. 384 pp.

Rita Koganzon
History of Education Quarterly · 2025 · 65(3) · pp. 435-439

Abstract

The study of education in any of the numerous humanistic and social-scientific disciplines in which it has taken root typically begins from the two intertwined premises: first, that education is mostly schooling, and second, that schooling is good. Schooling both develops individual intellectual and moral capacities, and it solves an array of social problems, from poverty and inequality to crime, prejudice, disease, and social conflict. Scholars of education consequently tend to lionize figures who’ve contributed to expanding schooling opportunities—the Horace Manns and Henry Barnards—and demonize those who’ve resisted them. Bold is the scholar willing to question this entire framework of unstated assumptions and to argue instead that the institution of mass schooling in the West was undertaken not to advance liberty and social progress, but rather to gain control over and indoctrinate unruly masses. This is the claim of Agustina Paglayan’s ambitious and important Raised to Obey: The Rise and Spread of Mass Education . Paglayan is a political scientist and approaches the origins of mass schooling comparatively and empirically. Examining the timing of major compulsory schooling legislation and primary schooling enrollment spikes across the nations of Western Europe and Latin America between the eighteenth and twentieth centuries, she tests these dates against contemporaneous political and economic developments in these nations to determine what led countries to invest in mass schooling. Her comparative analysis reveals that the main prevailing explanations for the origins of national compulsory schooling—that schooling was expanded to prepare citizens to discharge their new civic duties after extensions of the suffrage; that it was expanded in response to industrialization to train a more advanced labor force; that it was expanded to advance nationalist ambitions on disparate cultural communities by imposing a common language and national identity; or that it was expanded to serve modern military needs—all fail to line up with the historical timing of actual schooling expansions. Instead, what consistently preceded nationwide expansions of compulsory schooling was “destabilizing

Economic historyPolitical scienceEngineering physicsMedia studiesSociologyHistoryPhysics
Open in the catalogue DOI