historyofeducation.eu · Journals

The Complex Visions of Female Teachers and the Failure of Unionization in the 1930s: An Oral History

Richard A. Quantz
History of Education Quarterly · 1985 · 25(4) · pp. 439

Abstract

UNTIL RECENTLY, HISTORIANS have tended to treat teachers as nonpersons. Female teachers especially have been portrayed as objects rather than subjects, as either the unknowing tools of the social elite or as the exploited minority whose labor is bought cheaply. Rarely have they been treated as subjects in control of their own activities. Seldom has the world of schooling been presented through their eyes.'1 This essay attempts to reverse the traditional angle of vision and explore an educational event from the perspective of the teachers involved. Specifically it explores the failure of unions to organize teachers during the Great Depression. The failure of unionization among teachers in the first half of the twentieth century has not been ignored by historians. Joel Spring discusses the inability of organized labor to influence school boards or unionize teachers in Education and the Rise of the Corporate State. In The One Best System, David B. Tyack tells of administrative methods that wielded the hard club of threat and the false allures of professionalism. Both authors present these events as a conflict between unions and school elites for the allegiance of teachers. Both suggest that the elites won the battle to the detriment of teachers. For example, Spring blames the crushing power of corporate America and the conservatism of teachers for the failure of unionization, whereas Tyack points to the veiled coercion of administrators and teachers' naive desires for professional status. Although these arguments are forceful, both authors constructed their arguments with little input from teachers.2 Wayne Urban has provided one of the few analyses that include the voices of teachers. In Why Teachers Organized. Urban argues that

VisionOral historyPolitical scienceSociologyLabour economicsEconomicsAnthropology
Open in the catalogue DOI