historyofeducation.eu · Journals

State Government and American Public Education: Exploring the "Primeval Forest"

David Tyack, Thomas James
History of Education Quarterly · 1986 · 26(1) · pp. 39

Abstract

James Bryce observed in 1888 that who would understand the changes [in] the American democracy will find far more instruction in a study of the State governments than of the Federal Constitution. So neglected was the subject, he found, that could not even be called a field: it is rather a primeval forest, where the vegetation is rank, and through which scarcely a trail has yet been cut. Although Bryce himself cut one such path in The American Commonwealth, much of the terrain of state government in the nineteenth century remains unexplored to this day.' One can hardly say that the state's role in public education has been neglected. It was the organizing principle of the early chronicles of state school systems and a major concern in the influential writings of Ellwood P. Cubberley. The central theme of much of this pioneer work in educational history was the progressive evolution of the power of the state to standardize public schooling, a tale of reformist battles won and further professional goals to accomplish. In recent years historians of education have mostly bypassed state governments, although there are some important exceptions like Carl Kaestle's Pillars of the Republic. Critics of the Cubberleyan approach have attacked the earlier historiography for its celebratory tone, its narrowly institutional focus on matters of prime concern to educators, and its naive view of the political economy of

State (computer science)Government (linguistics)Public educationOld-growth forestState governmentPolitical sciencePublic administrationEconomic growthGeographySociologySocioeconomicsForestryLocal governmentEconomics
Open in the catalogue DOI