Colonial Colleges and English Dissenting Academies: A Study in Transatlantic Culture
Abstract
STUDENTS OF early American culture often seek its sources in the experiences of England's religious and political dissenters. One example is the thesis that England's dissenting academies stimulated Colonial colleges to become, as John Brubacher and Willis Rudy express it, broader and more modern in outlook. (1) Thomas Jefferson Wertenbaker calls the academies' influence matter of profound moment in the history of American education, while Richard Hofstadter, Lawrence Cremin, Brooke Hindle, and Francis Broderick emphasize the academies' and strong impact on college curricula. (2) Usually this influence is defined in terms of promoting the study of modern science and mathematics, although the academies also added new subjects like English composition, English literature, modern languages, and modern history, modified traditional subjects like Latin and ethics, and adopted new teaching methods like free discussion and the use of the vernacular. (3) The case for the academies' impact is plausible but not tenable. Its proponents have failed to examine carefully either the intellectual perspectives of colonial educators or the extent of their direct ties to the academies. The experience of Samuel Johnson exemplifies the pitfalls of pinpointing a source of influence like the academies. Shortly after Johnson became president of the newly founded College of New York in 1754, he and the trustees instituted a four-year curriculum that devoted almost two full years to science and mathematics. (4) What kinds of educational contacts might have shaped Johnson's