historyofeducation.eu · Journals

Ry Marcattilio-McCracken. The Incorrigibles: Eugenics and Sterilization in the Kansas Industrial School for Girls Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2023. 238 pp.

Abigail Jean Kahn
History of Education Quarterly · 2025 · 65(2) · pp. 298-300

Abstract

Marcattilio-McCracken’s The Incorrigibles joins a growing collection of case studies of sterilization programs in school settings, demonstrating through its meticulous analysis that there is still much to uncover about how eugenic policies in the United States were actualized at the local level. Focusing on the Beloit Girls’ Industrial School (GIS) in Kansas, the book reveals (and this is perhaps its most striking finding) that the pathways to sterilization at the GIS were highly unpredictable, even seemingly arbitrary, yet deeply rooted in specific institutional dynamics and the state-level interpretation of eugenic ideologies. The school’s approach to forced sterilization illuminates the inconsistent application of these policies and demonstrates the vital role of localized studies in decoding the manifestations of eugenic policy across the country. The book pursues two primary goals: first, to uncover the circumstances of Kansas’s sterilization policies, which were enacted upon over three thousand people in the state over fifty years; second, to chart what led many of the girls at the GIS to sterilization. The title The Incorrigibles draws from the most frequently cited reason girls were committed to the school— “incorrigibility,” a broad and malleable term used by GIS administrators that could mean anything from vagrancy to promiscuity, but ultimately meant that the girls’ behavior could not be controlled by their parents or schools and thus necessitated sending them to the specialized institution. The book first explores Kansas’s eugenics and social welfare policies in the broader national context. Though Kansas ranked twenty-ninth in population in 1940, it ranked sixth in states with the largest number of forced sterilizations. This surprising statistic is explained through a deep dive into the state’s position at the forefront of Progressive Era reforms, which included widening state power in social welfare. Kansas’s embrace

EugenicsSterilization (economics)GerontologyPolitical sciencePhilosophyMedicineLaw
Open in the catalogue DOI PDF