Education or Emigration: The Schism Within the African Colonization Movement, 1865-1875
Abstract
De Tocqueville saw but two choices: emancipation and amalgamation, or perpetual bondage. There was at least a third alternative; one that had been suggested several years before the visit of de Tocqueville and Beaumont. This proposal was that the difficulties concerning the status of the Negro could be solved by removing the alien and unwanted race. Plans for removal of the Negro from the United States took two forms, deportation and colonization. Actual deportation, in fact, occurred in the middle of the seventeenth century. Perhaps the best accounts of these early Negro deportations, as well as laws involved, can be found in the works of Walter L. Fleming (2) and Henry Noble Sherwood. (3) Sherwood tells us that, As early as 1646, Massachusetts returned to Africa a cargo of negroes [sic] landed on her shores, on the grounds that they had been