historyofeducation.eu · Journals

The Quest for Orderly Change: Some Reflections

Clarence H. Karier
History of Education Quarterly · 1979 · 19(2) · pp. 159

Abstract

The slightest reflection shows that conceptual material employed in writing history is that of period in which a history is written. There is no material available for leading principles and hypothesis save that of historic present. As culture changes, conceptions that are dominant in a culture change. Of necessity new standpoints for viewing, appraising and ordering data arise. History is then rewritten. (2) The year following Dewey's statement, Arthur 0. Lovejoy warned of danger in taking this idea to an extreme. To do so, he cautioned, was to confuse function of philosophy with history and fail to recognize that act of writing history involves not only present world of historian but more importantly world of past historical actor. While may, and often does, use ideas drawn from past historic actors for understanding his problematic present, historian's commitment is to transcend that present in order to better understand that past as it happened. It was John Dewey, the philosopher writing, when he said,

Neoclassical economicsPolitical scienceEpistemologyPhilosophyEconomics
Open in the catalogue DOI