The Influence of Humanism on the Education of Girls and Boys in Tudor England
Abstract
IN RECENT YEARS, statistics for Elizabethan and Stuart literacy levels, compiled by David Cressy, have challenged the familiar image of the period as a golden age of educational opportunity.' These figures can serve as the foundation for a new analysis of social mobility in the period, particularly among those below the level of the gentry. Yet the most striking figure among them is the one which is consistently the highest of all, regardless of the population sampled: the illiteracy rate for women.2 The number of women of all classes unable even to sign their names hovers around 90% and rises as high as 95 ? 3%; Cressy's figures obviously do not even consider complex reading comprehension or extensive writing ability, skills commonly associated with the spread of Renaissance culture through education.3 This paper examines educational theory and practice among the most privileged group in English society-the nobility and upper gentry-in an effort to describe the fundamental differences which distinguished the humanist program of study for girls from that for boys during the middle years of the sixteenth century. Even in this highly literate group, women were often taught only basic reading and writing, while their husbands, fathers and sons not only acquired specialized skills but gained access to a world from which the uneducated were permanently barred. The fundamental reasons for this split lay in the deeply divisive and misogynist nature of the educational program: both the theorists themselves and the texts they provided for young men emphasized specialization, categorization and difference.4 Thus, the introduction of humanist pedagogy, with its emphasis on classical texts and the niceties of style, into Tudor England had far-reaching effects not only on education but on the social structure of English society. By the mid-sixteenth century, humanism had become not simply a scholarly