Boundaries, Bridges, and the History of Education
Abstract
I first began to think about boundaries, although not about bridges, and the history of education when my first Ph.D. advisee walked into my office sixteen years ago to tell me about her dissertation topic. I'm going to look at the history of the world to see who got educated, who didn't get educated, and why, she announced. I was horrified. Needless to say, I soon persuaded her to abandon her boundless, boundaryless, topic for a neat do-able one with clearly defined boundaries of time, place, and subject. Two years later, my student had her degree. Sixteen years later, I am having second thoughts. What might she have produced if I had not fenced her in? I am not going to argue, today, that we do not need boundaries around our research topics. We do need them. Without clearly defined boundaries around our research topics, we could not tell what information was relevant, we would never know when a project was finished, and others would find our work unusable. What I am going to argue is that boundaries must be permeable. We must define our boundaries not only as barriers against the extraneous, but also as bridges, linking our work to ideas and perspectives from outside. I will talk briefly about the good things that have already happened because we have turned our boundaries into bridges in three areas-our subject matter, our discipline, and our chronological frameworks. Then I will talk at greater length about good things that I think will happen in yet another area when we do the same. Commentators inside and outside of the field agree that a revitalization has taken place in the history of education in recent decades.' This