Empowering Practitioners: Holmes, Carnegie, and the Lessons of History
Abstract
The national discussion about the future of American education and the teaching profession continues with the 1986 publication of two major reports: A Nation Prepared: Teachers for the Twenty-first Century and Tomorrow's Teachers: A Report of the Holmes Group. These reports, by the Carnegie Forum on Education and the Economy and by the Holmes Group, respectively, agree that the key to educational improvement is to create a career ladder for teachers which recognizes and rewards excellence, but they disagree over which group-practitioners or professorswe should look to for the advancement of professional knowledge and technique. The Carnegie Forum looks to the experience of outstanding teachers in the schools while the Holmes Group seeks to reassert the role of faculty in research universities in setting professional standards. In both reports, however, the recommendation that master teachers be identified rests upon the assumption that an agreed-upon body of scientific knowledge about teaching and learning now exists. This essay examines that assumption and the historical analogies in both reports to the medical profession at the turn of the twentieth century. The argument here is that the kind of scientific knowledge that transformed medical practice does not now exist in education. The more appropriate historical analogy is to the medical profession of the mid-nineteenth century, a profession splintered by sectarian and ideological controversy. Ironically, the twentieth-century attempt to make education more scientific appears only to have bred sectarians. The further historical irony is that during the 1920s and 1930s Dean Henry W. Holmes at Harvard University