historyofeducation.eu · Journals

William Seward and the New York School Controversy, 1840-1842: A Problem in Historical Motivation

Vincent Peter Lannie
History of Education Quarterly · 1966 · 6(1) · pp. 52

Abstract

HUMAN MOTIVATION is at best difficult to fathom, especially since complex and ambivalent man is frequently conditioned by multiple factors and motivated by many and often disparate considerations. The task is further complicated when one attempts to assess the motivational factors that induce a person to act one way instead of another in a particular situation. William Seward was one of those complex and ambivalent human beings whose actions were frequently conditioned by interacting motivational factors. He was at once a humanitarian and an ambitious partisan politician. When did Seward act from humanitarian impulses and when was he motivated by practical political considerations? This question is further compounded when the historian attempts to analyze the various degrees of idealism and pragmatism as they affected Seward's judgment upon a particular issue at a given time. The New York school question is a case in point. What were the sources that motivated Seward to present his educational recommendation to the New York State Legislature in 1840? Did this recommendation originate from an essentially humanitarian impulse or

SociologyEnvironmental ethicsHistoryPhilosophy
Open in the catalogue DOI