historyofeducation.eu · Journals

John Dewey and the Immigrants

J. Christopher Eisele
History of Education Quarterly · 1975 · 15(1) · pp. 67

Abstract

JOHN DEWEY has been the subject of comment and criticism for over three-quarters of a century. (1) Often, especially in recent writing on the history of education, the criticism has been divided between those who, to use Richard LaBreque's colorful language, see as the good guy and those who see him as the bad guy. (2) Among the latter, sometimes collectively called revisionists, are Clarence Karier, Walter Feinberg, and Colin Greer. Charles Tesconi and Van Cleve Morris have recently co-authored a book emphasizing similar themes. (3) Their attacks on and other liberals have centered around the rather vaguely defined issue of social control. (4) As Michael Katz says in his discussion of twentieth century school reform in Class, Bureaucracy and Schools, Nonetheless, there is a darker side to the social thought of even the best progressives, notably and Jane Addams,... Briefly, the emphasis on community in Jane Addams and the definitions of democracy and experience in provide particularly subtle and sophisticated instances the widespread attempt in their time to foster modes of social control appropriate to a complex urban environment. (5) Part of the evidence for the revisionists' stand on the social control issue comes from their perception of Dewey's position on the treatment of immigrants. For example, while discussing Dewey's views about one immigrant group, the Philadelphia Polish community, Karier says, Dewey viewed ethnic and religious differences as a threat to the survival of society, to be overcome through assimilation. Dewey, as well as other liberal reformers, was committed to flexible, experimentally managed, orderly social change that included a high degree of manipulation. (6) Greer generalizes this position to include all immigrants. (7) Morris and Tesconi continue the theme, although using different language, saying that Dewey's suggestion for the

CriticismImmigrationSociologyBureaucracySocial criticismSubject (documents)DemocracySocial controlLawPolitical scienceSocial sciencePolitics
Open in the catalogue DOI