historyofeducation.eu · Journals

School writings as sources for the study of teaching practices: the Italian case (1925-1945)

Juri Meda, Pozo Andrés, Carlos Menguiano-Rodríguez, María del Mar del Pozo Andrés, Gabriel Barceló Bauzà
History of Education & Children's Literature · 2020 · 15(2) · pp. 17-28

Abstract

Over the last twenty years, the historians of education who investigated the heuristic potential of school writings tended to focus on extraordinary historical periods (such as wars and revolutions) and to use notebooks and diaries not as sources able to describe how wars and dictatorships adulterated educational processes and teaching practices commonly promoted at school, but as materials to be used to tell how wars and dictatorships upset the lives of small protagonists in their school life or as unintentional written witnesses about social and political changes. Hence, the obsessive search for spontaneity as a guarantee of the reliability of the source, able to witness in a more natural and genuine way what was happening outside school and/or how this affected children’s lives inside school. This polarization generated a prevailing interest in what Davide Montino called disciplined writings. Starting from this assumption, this study tries to recover the production rejects of the strict selection process to which historians subjected these sources in search of the rare cases of evident spontaneity, and to re-evaluate them on the basis of a different interpretative parameter, that is reading their rhetoric, repetitiveness and stereotypy not as negative elements, but as real markers of a widespread teaching practice.

History of schoolHistory of teachingSchool writingSchool notebooksXXth Century
Open in the catalogue