historyofeducation.eu · Journals

La structuration des disciplines dans les universités allemandes du XIXe siècle

Stichweh, Rudolf, Pitz, Martina
Histoire de l'éducation · 1994 · 62(1) · pp. 55-73

Abstract

During the nineteenth century, academic subjects within German universities became increasingly differentiated Previous scholars have adopted three theoretical perspectives to consider this phenomenon. The first considers the individual history of each discipline ; the second approaches the subject from the perspective of the history of universities. And the last associates the history of the discipline with the external environment, considering how the latter fosters internal change. The author argues that these three approaches are not mutually exclusive when considering the phenomenon of differentiation. Indeed, they must be juxtaposed. Through a critical analysis of earlier work, Stichweh illustrates with specific examples how a variety of factors contributed to the evolution of each discipline. In philology, the new main discipline of the nineteenth century (to train intellectuals and select secondary schoolteachers), he considers how its social function developped both internally and externally. For the new experimental sciences, the author emphasizes the increasingly tight link between teaching and research. Finally, among the new sub-disciplines, he describes the establishment of scholarly communities at the national and international level. But the principal explanation for the diversification within German universities lies in the progressive creation of a competitive professional space among mobile teachers within a system that grew constantly in the second half of the nineteenth century. This growth inspired those who sought university positions to develop strategies of distinction and specialization that in turn fostered the creation of new disciplines. Individual and local innovations thus spread to the national level as regional universities sought to imitate, borrow and catch up witch each other.

Open in the catalogue DOI PDF